Plagiarized phd thesis

Plagiarized phd thesis

Jul 08,  · After discovering a few dodgy lines in a book, I found a PhD thesis full of ‘borrowed’ phrases – yet the cheat has faced no repercussions There were nearly copied sentences in one PhD Estimated Reading Time: 5 mins We received a complaint from an author claiming that her PhD thesis had been plagiarized in a journal article. After many discussions, the editorial office decided that the authors should resolve this issue among themselves, as it was an author dispute. After further correspondence, the editorial office is now also saying that because the thesis is not published anywhere, there is no need to cite it in the Self-Plagiarism in PhD thesis. Ask Question Asked 7 years, 11 months ago. Active 3 years, 11 months ago. Viewed 57k times 69 I am a final year PhD in UK in a scientific discipline and I am writing my thesis. I have already published 2 journal papers and I have submitted 2 more papers for publications

Plagiarism of a PhD thesis | COPE: Committee on Publication Ethics

Early last year, I was looking through the first book of a creative writing graduate. It was a book of poems based on their PhD, and I recognised some of the lines in it as possibly plagiarised. When I looked harder, I found chunks from blogs and other websites, chopped up with line-breaks, no quote marks and no acknowledgements.

Clearly, poetry written as part of a doctorate should not such show cavalier disregard for referencing. For more than 12 months afterwards, I was unable to verify whether these plagiarisms were also in the bound PhD thesis. I plagiarized phd thesis with the British Library because they have rights to a second copy and only need to ask the awarding plagiarized phd thesis for it through the Electronic Thesis Online Service Ethos. I asked them to request it, but the awarding university or the author said no.

My contact with the lecturer went quiet, so I made a handful of freedom of information requests to the university, asking when the PhD would go back into the library and if there was any sort of plagiarism enquiry under way.

In each case it took 10 days for them to reply. Each reply would invite a follow-up question. Confidentiality needed to be respected, they said. Could they give a time frame, I replied. Why not? No answer. The university said yes. I also received an email telling me that the PhD thesis would be going back onto the shelves that weekend, and on to Ethos at the British Library. Moreover, there was a critical component: a long essay about contemporary poetry, plagiarized phd thesis, comprising two-thirds of the PhD.

This is the part where candidates show their academic ability. But I found this prose component was also rife with uncredited verbatim sentences from other academic criticism. Sentences specifically discussing one artwork had been cut and pasted to refer to another; sentences about an exhibition of painting were applied to an anthology of poems; sentences about the specifics of one poem inspired by jazz were transposed to discuss a poem by a completely different author.

It was waffle. I vetted the thesis and found that it had 75 pages with uncredited verbatim sentences, often more than one per page. Sometimes plagiarized phd thesis were from items cited in the bibliography, suggesting amateur citation skills — cut and paste instead of paraphrase even though the candidate knew full well to use quote marks when quoting elsewhere in the thesis.

On at least 10 occasions sentences were from items not cited in the bibliography at all, but from academic articles and reviews. You could make a case for postmodern ghosting in creative writing, but copying verbatim sentences from uncredited sources in a critical analysis is simply academic plagiarism.

I wonder what will happen if I report these latest findings. Will the university remove the bound thesis from the shelves, and deny permission to plagiarized phd thesis British Library for use of its copy?

Will it investigate? Will it stall its response again? This PhD sets a precedent that suggests other candidates would not have their doctorates stripped from them for using multiple uncredited texts in their creative writing.

This also sets a precedent that a Plagiarized phd thesis with nearly a verbatim borrowings in its critical writing does not lead to the removal of the doctorate from the doctor, plagiarized phd thesis. This creates a legal minefield, one that other universities should be concerned about.

Join the higher education network for more comment, analysis and job opportunities, direct to your inbox. Follow us on Twitter gdnhighered. And if you have an idea for a story, plagiarized phd thesis, please read our guidelines and email your pitch to us at highereducationnetwork theguardian.

Education Schools Teachers Universities Students. Academics anonymous Universities. This article is more than 5 years old.

There were nearly copied sentences in one PhD thesis. Fri 8 Jul Bad PhD supervisors can ruin research, plagiarized phd thesis. So why aren't they accountable? Read more, plagiarized phd thesis. I'm not LMAO at ridiculous emails from my students. Our obsession with metrics turns academics into data drones. Topics Universities Academics anonymous Academics PhDs Higher education comment.

Reuse this content.

How to Paraphrase without Plagiarising - Essay Writing Made Easy

, time: 8:57

ethics - Who is responsible for detecting plagiarism in a PhD thesis? - Academia Stack Exchange

May 04,  · His doctoral thesis (archived link) is titled The Quantification of Information Systems Risk: A Look at Quantitative Responses to Information Security Issues. Substantial, deliberate plagiarism Estimated Reading Time: 9 mins Self-Plagiarism in PhD thesis. Ask Question Asked 7 years, 11 months ago. Active 3 years, 11 months ago. Viewed 57k times 69 I am a final year PhD in UK in a scientific discipline and I am writing my thesis. I have already published 2 journal papers and I have submitted 2 more papers for publications Jul 08,  · After discovering a few dodgy lines in a book, I found a PhD thesis full of ‘borrowed’ phrases – yet the cheat has faced no repercussions There were nearly copied sentences in one PhD Estimated Reading Time: 5 mins